Daniel Cohen
God’s Unchanging Hand, p.2

It's worth remembering that the Christian Right almost gave up on a “moral majority” in this country during the Clinton years, particularly when, in the midst of the Lewinsky scandal, the Democrats actually picked up seats in the 1998 election. Many prominent figures on the Christian Right openly called for a kind of cultural secession. Give up on this society, they said; home-school your kids. And we'll be back someday.

Well, they're back. The Christian right now has the momentum to make up for, and go beyond, their earlier tactical retreats. Bush showed appreciation for his base by signing the partial-birth abortion ban, one of the steps Kaplan identifies as beginning a process that will end by ultimately reversing Roe v. Wade. Secular social programs have been starved of federal funding, while "faith-based initiatives" have resulted in the awarding of millions of taxpayer dollars in grants to Christian organizations. Kaplan finds it suspicious that there is scant Jewish and Muslim participation in Bush’s faith-based plans, arguing that the government is supporting Christians, though, of course, this is only speculation.

Perhaps the most inauspicious move on the administration’s part was replacing career science experts on committees with Christian fundamentalists to skew data on condoms and stem cells. Kaplan sees this as another instance of Bush’s principle of silencing dissenting information. Now, countries like Israel and South Korea are ahead of the U.S. in extracting stem cells from cloned embryos. Kaplan, though, is really arguing substance, not process; her dogma of science disregards that of religion, but for many people in this country, traditional moral values - as mediated and interpreted by authority figures - are more important than financial or scientific opportunity.

This selective blindness is part of a larger phenomenon. Kaplan believes Bush’s moves are entirely political -- to strengthen his constituency -- even though Bush himself seems to "speak the language" of right-wing Christianity, and even though, if Bush is lying about his religiosity, he has succeeded in fooling legions of true believers. Kaplan seems so wedded to her belief that governments always act in the interests of political expediency, that she cannot conceive that Bush et al might sincerely be acting for the greater good of the community as they see it. Ironically, since Kaplan seems chiefly concerned with a weakening of the Constitution as she understands it, Bush is more of a danger to her values if he is sincere than if he is merely a schemer.

Although I disagree with her conclusions, With God on Their Side is a great book to read: Kaplan keeps it lively with impressive facts and a sarcastic style that rails against the policies of a president who “shed the mantle of moderation very quickly.” Her tone is of wonder, of being awestruck by Bush. She is indignant at his scratch-my-back-I’ll-scratch-yours style, and how he has mowed down any obstacle whether he has understood it or not. Kaplan’s book is a clear illustration of his métier, though her liberal lens lends to a baffled tone that fails to understand that, with his charisma, that is how he gets things done. Kaplan's politics lead her to be more baffled than ultimately admiring of the president. Yet her tone is that of one awestruck, as if by a Divine force.

[1]       2
Image: Jesus Macarena-Avila, My bush is the only one I trust

Daniel Cohen is from New York and has a degree in Middle Eastern Studies from Harvard

Email us your comments


Deconstructing Zell Miller Jay Michaelson
Reality and rhetoric in an election year
October, 2004

Where Left and Right Collide Dan Friedman
A debate between the author of "A Jewish Critique of Bushism" and the head of "L.A. for Bush"
October, 2004

The Spiritual Foundations of Bushism Jay Michaelson
The deep structure of the American Right's appeal
August, 2004

Art at War Bara Sapir
Artists on 9/11 and the war on/of terror
October, 2004

Davening with Joe Michael Shurkin
To fear a Jewish president
February, 2004

Some things have changed, some have stayed the same Jay Michaelson
Alienated politics in an age of ignorance
December, 2002

Manufacturing Dissent Chad Beck
For the Left's voice to be heard, it needs to play by the rules
November, 2002

Enraged in the Enron Age Dan Friedman
The rich are ripping us off! What are you gonna do about it?
April, 2002

March 2005

Shakey: An Essay on Anger
Jay Michaelson

Giving Thanks to Elijah the Prophet in Indian Manhattan
Jonathan Schorsch

Three Nights
Jill Hammer

The Pursuit of Justice
Emily Rosenberg

Sha'arei Tzedek
Dan Friedman

God's Unchanging Hand
Daniel Cohen

Our 610 Back Pages

Neurotic Visionaries & Paranoid Jews
April 7, 2005

Zeek in Print
Fall/Winter 2004 issue now on sale

About Zeek

Mailing List

Contact Us


Tech Support



From previous issues:

French Antisemitism
Michael Shurkin

Counterculture and Democracy
Jay Michaelson

The Red-Green Alliance
Dave Hyde